CCPartners | Blog

Date:
2026.11.17

Related Blogs by Category
Employment Litigation

Share:

Print:

THE EMPLOYERS' EDGE

When Confidentiality Meets Discovery: The Limits of Withholding Mitigation Evidence

Practice Areas: Employment Litigation

A confidentiality clause is not a blanket exemption from documentary production. Where a document is relevant to an issue in dispute, a party seeking to withhold it must establish a proper basis for doing so, and general assertions of confidentiality may not be enough.

In a recent decision, Crawford v. Stingray Group Inc., 2026 ONSC 5772, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice considered whether a wrongful dismissal plaintiff could withhold correspondence and an employment offer received from a subsequent employer. The Court ordered production of the unredacted documents and awarded the defendant $25,000 in costs. The decision also offers useful guidance on confidentiality objections and on counsel's responsibilities when reviewing documents before production.

Background

The plaintiff was employed by the defendant for approximately ten months before his employment ended on March 6, 2020. He received an offer of employment from another organization on June 1, 2020, began working there on June 15, 2020, and commenced a wrongful dismissal action.

During discovery, the plaintiff produced a heavily redacted email containing the employment offer but withheld its attachments and his other correspondence with the subsequent employer. He relied on the confidentiality provisions in his employment agreement, the competitive relationship between the two organizations, and the suggestion that the defendant should seek the documents from the subsequent employer directly.

The Court's Findings

1. Subsequent employment is relevant to damages
The defendant's Statement of Defence alleged a failure to mitigate and sought to deduct any income earned after termination. The Court found the correspondence relevant to both issues. The employer bears the onus of proving a failure to mitigate; however, citing Red Deer College v. Michaels, 1975 CanLII 15 (SCC), the Court noted that much of the information needed to do so is in the plaintiff's hands. Income received after termination must also be accounted for in calculating the loss.

Practical significance: Employers should identify early the documents needed to test both the plaintiff's mitigation efforts and the income loss claimed. That record may extend well beyond an employment contract or pay records.

2. A confidentiality objection requires evidence, not simply an assertion
Rather than accepting the plaintiff's characterization of the provision, the Court looked closely at what it actually covered. Its focus was the plaintiff's own compensation; it did not, in the Court's words, "identify nor protect any confidential or sensitive business information" of the subsequent employer (para. 16). The plaintiff had also received the documents before he began working for the subsequent employer, so no contractual obligation prevented their production.

The alleged harm to the subsequent employer fared no better. That employer did not seek standing or file evidence, and the plaintiff's information-and-belief account of its counsel's concerns was given no weight. The contrast with Chuang v. Toyota Canada, 2013 ONSC 3235, was the third party's own involvement; there, the non-parties obtained standing and put their own evidence before the Court, while here the subsequent employer remained on the sidelines.

Practical significance: Employers should test whether a confidentiality objection identifies a legitimate interest. If a third party's commercial interests are genuinely at stake, the evidence should come from that third party.

3. The source of a document does not determine who must produce it
Rule 30.02 requires parties to produce relevant documents within their possession, control or power. Since the plaintiff already held the documents, the Court saw no reason for the defendant to proceed under Rule 30.10. Employers need not incur the time and expense of a non-party motion where the plaintiff has the records.

4. Counsel, not the client, controls redactions
In a footnote, the Court noted that the plaintiff had redacted the email himself before providing it to his lawyer. Redaction before production should be rare; where it is contemplated, counsel must obtain the unredacted document and make that assessment independently. A client's preference to withhold information is not, by itself, a sufficient basis for doing so.

The Cost of an Unsuccessful Position

The $25,000 costs award, inclusive of HST and disbursements, reflected the plaintiff's changing explanations for refusing production, which required the motion to proceed in two stages. The Court was also critical of the timing of the plaintiff's concession on the confidentiality clause. Its production was only agreed to once the first stage of the motion was before the Court, a step the Court found should have been taken well in advance (para. 27). Notably, one of the defendant's own affidavits was given no weight because it contained opinion evidence, a reminder that supporting evidence must be properly grounded.

Takeaways for Employers

  1. Identify mitigation evidence early, including correspondence, offers, contracts and post-termination earnings. The scope of production will depend on the issues raised in the pleadings and the relevance of the documents sought.
  2. Do not accept a confidentiality clause as an automatic answer; consider what it actually protects and what evidence of harm exists.
  3. Where the plaintiff holds the records, rely on Rule 30.02 rather than a non-party motion.
  4. Bring a refusals motion where relevant documents remain outstanding. Success can bring both production and a meaningful costs award.
  5. Ensure counsel reviews original documents and determine whether any proposed redactions are legally justified.

Contac one of the lawyers at CCPartners to discuss the above.

Click HERE to access CCPartners’ “Lawyers for Employers” podcasts on important workplace issues and developments in labour and employment law.

 

News

Menu

Crawford Chondon & Partners LLP is committed to providing an inclusive workplace that embraces and respects differences.  We support and promote the ongoing development, implementation and maintenance of best practices and strategies to enhance and improve equality, diversity and inclusion within the Firm, in advising clients and in the greater community. Click to learn more about our Diversity and Inclusion 

Main Office Map
6985 Financial Drive

Suite 503
Mississauga, ON  L5N 0G3


P: 905.874.9343  TF: 1.877.874.9343
F: 905.874.1384  E: info@ccpartners.ca
Barrie Office  Map

132 Commerce Park Drive
Suite 253, Unit K
Barrie, ON L4N 0Z7


P: 705.719.2107 F: 1.866.525.8128

E: rboswell@ccpartners.ca 

Sudbury Office  Map

10 Elm Street
Suite 603
Sudbury Ontario P3C 5N3
 

P: 705.805.0174

E: info@ccpartners.ca 

Privacy | Accessibility | Disclaimer

© 2013 CRAWFORD CHONDON & PARTNERS LLP