CCPartners | Blog


Related Blogs by Category
Wrongful Dismissal
Employment Litigation




Pension Benefits Cannot be Deducted from Employee Entitlements on Termination

Last week the Supreme Court of Canada delivered a ruling to clarify what has been an unsettled issue in employment law.  In a wrongful termination disputeIBM Canada Limited v. Waterman  (2013 SCC 70) Canada’s highest Court heard an appeal from the British Columbia Court of Appeal with regard to Waterman’s entitlements on termination.

Waterman was a long-term employee who had been wrongfully dismissed by IBM.  After his employment ended, Waterman began drawing from his pension benefits, and then launched his claim for wrongful dismissal damages.  At trial, he was awarded pay in lieu of notice of termination equivalent to 20 months’ salary. 

IBM took the position that since Waterman had been in receipt of pension benefits, he was not also entitled to collect pay in lieu of notice.  In the company’s view, this would be a form of “double-dipping” whereby Waterman would get to collect twice for the same loss.  Its position was that since a wrongfully dismissed employee is only entitled to be compensated for his or her actual losses, IBM ought not be responsible to pay the full amount in lieu of notice if Waterman already mitigated his losses by receiving pension benefits.  Accordingly, the employer argued that the wrongful dismissal award ought to be reduced by the amount  Waterman had already collected from drawing the pension benefits.

The Supreme Court of Canada disagreed.  It ruled that Waterman was not recovering double compensation for the loss of his employment by seeking pay in lieu of notice after having drawn from his pension benefits.  Rather, the Court drew a distinction by stating, in part:

In general, a benefit would not be deducted if it was not an indemnity for the loss caused by the breach and the plaintiff had contributed in order to obtain entitlement to it.

The pension benefits, to which Waterman had contributed throughout his employment, were never intended to be an indemnity for the type of loss suffered as a consequence of the wrongful dismissal.  On the other hand, the intent of wrongful dismissal damages in the form of pay in lieu of notice of termination is to ease the burden of loss of employment and help bridge the transition to new employment, or retirement.

The significance of this ruling for employers is a warning to be a more certain and cautious when calculating potential wrongful dismissal damages.  While a terminated employee is required to mitigate his or her losses, and should only recover damages to compensate for the loss of employment, the Supreme Court of Canada has made it clear that a terminated employee’s entitlements for wrongful dismissal damages will not be off-set if they draw from their pension benefits during the reasonable notice period.

If you are trying to determine an employee’s entitlements on termination the lawyers at CCPartners have ample experience and insight to assist you in making the right call.

Please Note: This blog has been prepared as an informational service for our clients and other interested parties. It is not intended to constitute legal advice, a complete statement of the law or opinion on any subject. Although we endeavour to ensure the accuracy of the content, no one should act upon the information provided without a thorough examination of the law after the facts of a specific situation are fully considered.



Crawford Chondon & Partners LLP is committed to providing an inclusive workplace that embraces and respects differences.  We support and promote the ongoing development, implementation and maintenance of best practices and strategies to enhance and improve equality, diversity and inclusion within the Firm, in advising clients and in the greater community. Click to learn more about our Diversity and Inclusion 

Main Office Map
24 Queen Street E.

Suite 500
Brampton, ON  L6V 1A3

P: 905.874.9343  TF: 1.877.874.9343
F: 905.874.1384  E:
Barrie Office  Map

132 Commerce Park Drive
Suite 253, Unit K
Barrie, ON L4N 0Z7

P: 705.719.2107 F: 1.866.525.8128


Sudbury Office  Map

10 Elm Street
Suite 603
Sudbury Ontario P3C 5N3

P: 705.805.0174


Privacy | Accessibility | Disclaimer